Skip to main content
Presidential Profiles

Rutherford B. Hayes: The First President to Lose the Popular Vote

Rutherford B. Hayes (1822–1893) became the 19th president of the United States in 1877. He was the first president to be elected by the Electoral College despite losing the popular vote, which earned him the nickname…

Share
GettyImages-1410622523 Rutherford B. Hayes
Rutherford B. Hayes (Photo by Heritage Art/Heritage Images via Getty Images)

Rutherford B. Hayes (1822–1893) became the 19th president of the United States in 1877. He was the first president to be elected by the Electoral College despite losing the popular vote, which earned him the nickname “His Fraudulency” by his opponents.

Hayes was born on Oct. 4, 1822 in Delaware, Ohio. His father had passed away just two months before his birth. He received his education at Kenyon College and Harvard Law School and then practiced law for about five years.

Tilden-Hayes Affair

Hayes ran for president in the 1876 election, but it looked like the Democrats were going to win, so he went to bed that night thinking he had lost. The Republican National Chairman Zachariah Chandler found a loophole and sent a wire saying “Hayes has 185 votes and is elected.” Samuel J. Tilden had the popular vote with 4,300,000, while Hayes had 4,036,000.

The presidential seat now depended upon electoral votes in Florida, Louisiana, and South Carolina, which had been contested by Hayes’ campaign managers. For months, Congress tried to figure out how to accurately tell the results and finally created an Electoral Commission to make the decision. On March 2, 1877, the Commission decided that all the contested votes would go to Hayes, making the final tally 185 for Hayes and 184 electoral votes for Tilden. This contentious dispute became known as the Tilden-Hayes affair.

President Rutherford B. Hayes

The Civil War had caused a lot of bad feelings between the Southern and Northern states. Hayes wanted to try and heal some of the rifts and included an ex-Confederate to his staff, which outraged some of the Northern supporters. He appointed more Southerners to federal positions and kept his promise to withdraw the troops from states that were still under occupation, which led to the end of the Reconstruction era.

Hayes’ presidency had been about building up the South and strengthening the Republican Party; however, the hostility between the northern and southern states was still too great and ended up almost virtually destroying the Republican Party in the South.

He chose not to run for president for another term and in retirement devoted his time to other causes such as educational opportunities for black youth in the South and prison reform. He died on Jan. 17, 1893, at the age of 70.

U.S. Presidents

Try a quiz based on this article

10 questions · about 3 minutes
01

In what year did Rutherford B. Hayes become the 19th President of the United States?

Show the answer

1877.

02

After being elected by the Electoral College, even though he lost the popular vote, Hayes was nicknamed by his opponents as:

Show the answer

His Fraudulency.

03

Hayes was born on Oct. 4, 1822, in what US state?

Show the answer

Ohio.

04

Who ran against Hayes in the 1876 presidential election?

Show the answer

Samuel J. Tilden.

05

To determine the winner, Congress created an Electoral Commission to decide how to count the Electoral votes.

Show the answer

True.

06

At what university did Hayes earn his law degree?

Show the answer

Harvard Law School.

07

Hayes wanted to repair the relationship between the North and South after what major war?

Show the answer

Civil War.

08

In his attempts to heal the conflict, Hayes hired an ex-Confederate to his staff.

Show the answer

True.

09

Hayes’ efforts to strengthen the South and build the Republican Party backfired and virtually destroyed the Republican Party in the:

Show the answer

South.

10

After his presidency, Hayes spent his time working on prison reform and with black youth. He died on:

Show the answer

Jan. 17, 1893.

0 of 10 answeredThe weekly quiz →
Share

Know someone who should read this?

Written by

Kelli Ballard

National Correspondent at LibertyNation.com and Generation Liberty. Kelli Ballard is an author, editor, and publisher. Her writing interests span many genres including a former crime/government reporter, fiction novelist, and playwright. Originally a Central California girl, Kelli now resides in the Seattle area.

Read next

Benjamin Harrison: The Second President in His Family

News, civics, and history for the next generation, grounded in America’s founding principles.

Donor Supported

Generation Liberty is free because people who value its purpose pay for it.

You can donate, too.

Donate
© 2026 A Project of One Generation Away